Is AI now clouding human critical thinking abilities?

Artificial Intelligence

Observers say Beijing is massively investing in AI.

Photo credit: Shutterstock

In the ever-evolving landscape of artificial intelligence (AI) tools like ChatGPT, a question looms large in the minds of many: Can the widespread availability of information from these generative AI tools chip away at our critical thinking abilities?

The answer, my friends, is a resounding no. Critical thinking, that precious ability to dissect information and arrive at informed decisions based on evidence and logic, remains an inherently human trait that cannot be replicated by machines.

Let’s break it down. AI tools are designed as tools, mind you, tools that assist us in various tasks. They can provide access to a wealth of information, crunch complex computations and even generate insights. However, the onus lies on us, the users, to employ our critical faculties to analyse and interpret the information these tools furnish.

Here’s the scoop on AI models like ChatGPT. They have their limitations. They gain their smarts by sifting through copious amounts of data, and their responses are rooted in patterns and correlations found within that data. While we strive for accuracy, biases can seep in, and inaccuracies may surface. That’s why it’s essential for users to evaluate the information, fact-check when necessary and thoughtfully consider multiple perspectives.


Now, let’s get real. These AI tools lack the nuanced understanding and common-sense reasoning that only we humans possess. They operate on statistical patterns, not genuine comprehension.

Picture this: If you’re worried about your health, you can feed an AI your symptoms, and it can suggest potential ailments along with possible treatments. But remember, it won’t possess the instinct a doctor has to observe other signs, delve deeper into your symptoms, and use that additional information to prescribe the best course of action.

Ultimately, the responsibility for critical thinking falls squarely on our shoulders. It’s up to us to nurture and apply those critical thinking skills when engaging with AI tools. We must question assumptions, evaluate sources, acknowledge biases, and seek out additional information to paint a complete picture.

Diverse perspectives

But wait, there’s more! AI tools can actually be allies in the quest for critical thinking. They can grant us access to diverse perspectives, invite exploration of different viewpoints, and ignite thought-provoking discussions.

 By actively and critically engaging with these AI tools, we can hone our own critical thinking abilities.

Yet, here’s the thing to remember. When it comes to children, caution is warranted. If they become overly reliant on AI tools for homework, it may impede their development of critical thinking skills, creativity and problem-solving prowess.

Educators, this message is for you. To promote critical thinking and creativity, consider fostering collaborative learning environments where children can freely exchange ideas, share perspectives and collaborate on assignments. Such discussions with peers, teachers and mentors can refine ideas, ignite deeper analysis and fortify those critical thinking muscles.

Mr Wambugu is an accredited expert in cloud and cyber security. Email: [email protected] Twitter: @Samwambugu2