Women pay double to access mobile money services

Kenyan women are paying almost twice as much as their male counterparts to access mobile money services, according to a new report.

Data released by British digital payments research firm Caribou Data shows the multiple ways in which women play second fiddle in the utility of Safaricom’s fintech products, M-Pesa, M-Shwari and Fuliza.

According to the report, Payments System Design and the Financial Inclusion Gender Gap, the study conducted in major towns across the country shows a strong gender bias in transaction fees, with women paying about Sh11 per peer-to-peer transaction, compared with Sh7 for men, on average.

“It leads to a higher average of total fees paid per month, about Sh30 for women and Sh16 for men,” states the study funded by the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation.

This, the survey explains, is due to the fact that women are less financially empowered, making them transact smaller amounts – usually less than Sh800 per transaction on average – which attracts higher transaction fees compared with men, who send bigger amounts on Safaricom’s mobile money platform M-Pesa.

Currently, to send Sh800 you are required to pay a transaction fee of Sh12, which is 1.5 per cent of the transaction value, compared with sending Sh15,000 at a fee of Sh97, which translates to 0.64 per cent of the amount sent.

Safaricom’s dominance

Safaricom’s dominant market position has allowed it to maintain relatively high fees, starting at Sh10 (before the Covid-19 pandemic) for transactions between Sh101 to Sh500. Consequently, users pay an average fee of about 1.5 per cent of the transaction value in fees, with women averaging a significantly higher fee burden over men.

This changed when Safaricom raised the fee threshold from Sh100 to Sh1,000 in response to Covid-19 economic hardships, where higher values were transacted. The survey also discloses that despite the telco’s overdraft facility Fuliza witnessing a stronger demand from men than women, it is the latter who are more active.

Launched in November 2018, with a daily borrowing of Sh830 million according to data released by Safaricom last November, Fuliza has become common, with 21 per cent of women and 26 per cent of men using it, according to the research.

 “While fewer women used the service, those who did were more active than their male counterparts. Women averaged four transactions at an average value of Sh140 each, compared to men averaging 1.6 transactions for Sh80 each,” states the research that surveyed over 1000 men and women.

Women’s high utilisation of Fuliza suggests that innovative new mobile money products — in this case a wallet-integrated credit facility — may be valuable in serving their unmet financial needs.

According to Roselyne Wanjiru, a decentralised finance expert at Kesholabs, Nairobi, most women are mothers taking care of children, and smaller transaction amounts are expected from them due to their many frequent household expenses.

“Men can be said to spend more on family and external high risk investments. They also tend to ask for more work opportunities, promotions and executive level positions than women do,” she told Sunday Nation.

She adds that it's an offshoot of a primarily patriarchal Kenyan society in the sense that it is only in recent years where more women were seen in executive and top level corporate positions that pay huge salaries.

“The country is yet to embrace a culture of equal work for equal pay in Kenya whereby a male graduate in one company can be earning more at an entry level than their female senior in another company with more experience,” she notes.

But both genders, the study found out, are more encouraged to send amounts less than Sh100 that attract no fees, with 25 percent of Safaricom’s 29 million active M-Pesa users completely avoiding  sending amounts higher than Sh100.

Digital savings accounts

“Men had a slightly higher proportion of their peer-to-peer payments threshold of Sh100 at 27 per cent compared to women at 22 per cent. Interestingly, we see no substantive difference in this fee avoidance behavior based on income.”

On M-Shwari, which has boosted widespread adoption of digital savings accounts, 19 per cent of men are saving their cash, slightly outpacing women (14 per cent).

Alice Anangi, founder and chief executive of Nairobi-based Zeden Technologies says that the current economic situation in Kenya places women at a higher risk of poverty than men due to cultural factors in decision making and allocation of resources.

“We are seeing unfavourable enrolment ratios in institutions, early marriages and low women exposure to digital financial inclusion. There is a traditional culture encouraged by society for women to go for courses of less masculine roles and technology that pay well. This in turn leads to fewer women enjoying a higher disposable income,” she expounds.

Both genders averaged almost 2.5 savings-related transactions per month, but women had a median value more than twice as high as men - Sh548 versus Sh219. However men remain more active on the platform, especially in the locked savings product.

Financial services

Further, the study shows that Kenyan women are more likely to use cheap and low performing mobile phones, which serves as yet another barrier to effective use of financial services.

Cheap devices typically struggle to run multiple apps simultaneously, because they have insufficient free space to keep the apps installed.

“Unsurprisingly, women take a greater share of devices at costing less than Sh20,000. Those costing more are more likely to be owned by men,” says the study.

Ms Wanjiru sees this as a result of women being less exposed than men pertaining to the access of a wider range of financial services.

“There's a need for increased financial literacy on women to increase demand for digital financial services aside from loans, such as micro lending and interest earning, fractional investments, fractional property ownership and alternative investments,” she says.

Most respondents are using lower-end smartphones costing less than Sh10,000 at 54 per cent , and almost all of them, 92 per cent, are using devices costing less than Sh20,000.

Respondents who can afford more expensive mobile phones transacted more frequently and for an average higher total value.

“Across all five markets, those with higher-end phones (defined as Sh20,000 retail pricing) had a total median transaction value of Sh1,647 per month compared to Sh878 per month for lower-end device owners.”

They also transacted more frequently, at more than 7 transactions per month compared to 4 for cheap handset owners.

According to Roselyne Wanjiru, a decentralised finance expert at Kesholabs, Nairobi, most women are mothers taking care of children, and smaller transaction amounts are expected from them due to their many frequent household expenses.

“Men can be said to spend more on family and external high risk investments. They also tend to ask for more work opportunities, promotions and executive level positions than women do,” she told Sunday Nation.

She adds that it's an offshoot of a primarily patriarchal Kenyan society in the sense that it is only in recent years where more women were seen in executive and top level corporate positions that pay huge salaries.

“The country is yet to embrace a culture of equal work for equal pay in Kenya whereby a male graduate in one company can be earning more at an entry level than their female senior in another company with more experience,” she notes.

But both genders, the study found out, are more encouraged to send amounts less than Sh100 that attract no fees, with 25 percent of Safaricom’s 29 million active M-Pesa users completely avoiding  sending amounts higher than Sh100.

Digital savings accounts

“Men had a slightly higher proportion of their peer-to-peer payments threshold of Sh100 at 27 per cent compared to women at 22 per cent. Interestingly, we see no substantive difference in this fee avoidance behavior based on income.”

On M-Shwari, which has boosted widespread adoption of digital savings accounts, 19 per cent of men are saving their cash, slightly outpacing women (14 per cent).

Alice Anangi, founder and chief executive of Nairobi-based Zeden Technologies says that the current economic situation in Kenya places women at a higher risk of poverty than men due to cultural factors in decision making and allocation of resources.

“We are seeing unfavourable enrolment ratios in institutions, early marriages and low women exposure to digital financial inclusion. There is a traditional culture encouraged by society for women to go for courses of less masculine roles and technology that pay well. This in turn leads to fewer women enjoying a higher disposable income,” she expounds.

Both genders averaged almost 2.5 savings-related transactions per month, but women had a median value more than twice as high as men - Sh548 versus Sh219. However men remain more active on the platform, especially in the locked savings product.

Financial services

Further, the study shows that Kenyan women are more likely to use cheap and low performing mobile phones, which serves as yet another barrier to effective use of financial services.

Cheap devices typically struggle to run multiple apps simultaneously, because they have insufficient free space to keep the apps installed.

“Unsurprisingly, women take a greater share of devices at costing less than Sh20,000. Those costing more are more likely to be owned by men,” says the study.

Ms Wanjiru sees this as a result of women being less exposed than men pertaining to the access of a wider range of financial services.

“There's a need for increased financial literacy on women to increase demand for digital financial services aside from loans, such as micro lending and interest earning, fractional investments, fractional property ownership and alternative investments,” she says.

Most respondents are using lower-end smartphones costing less than Sh10,000 at 54 per cent , and almost all of them, 92 per cent, are using devices costing less than Sh20,000.

Respondents who can afford more expensive mobile phones transacted more frequently and for an average higher total value.

“Across all five markets, those with higher-end phones (defined as Sh20,000 retail pricing) had a total median transaction value of Sh1,647 per month compared to Sh878 per month for lower-end device owners.”

They also transacted more frequently, at more than 7 transactions per month compared to 4 for cheap handset owners.

[email protected]